Surviving the Peer Review Process

This webinar will present practical tips and strategies for surviving the peer review process, and is run by the BAM Peer Review College (PRC) and Early Career Academic Network (ECA).

Description

This webinar will present practical tips and strategies for surviving the peer review process, and is run by the BAM Peer Review College (PRC) and Early Career Academic Network (ECA). A number of speakers from the PRC will share their experiences of peer review including dealing with different types of paper rejection, the psychological impact of rejection, tackling and responding to reviewer comments, developing peer support networks, and managing the risks of peer review through a portfolio of projects.


Benefits of Attendance
  • Learn from the experiences of scholars across a range of disciplines
  • Develop practical tips and strategies for surviving the peer review process
  • Interactive discussions with experienced members and fellows of PRC
  • Access to key references and recommended readings on Peer Review

Agenda

14:00

Welcome and Introduction

Sahar Bakr (ECA director),
Rebecca Beech (ECA Director), Dermot Breslin (PRC Dean)
  • Introduction to surviving peer review
  • Introduction to ECA and PRC

14:15

Dealing with paper rejection

Nisreen Ameen (PRC Member)
Sahar Bakr (ECA director)
  • Dealing with desk rejections
  • Dealing with rejection after review
  • The emotional and psychological impact of rejection
  • Peer and institutional support

14:45

Tackling the revise and resubmit process

Paul Jones (PRC Fellow)
Rebecca Beech (ECA Director)
  • Making sense of reviewer comments
  • Balancing competing demands
  • Responding to editor and reviewers

15:15

Managing a portfolio of research projects

Martin Spring (PRC Fellow)

  • Managing the risks in peer review
  • Developing networks of scholars
  • Developing a support network

15:45

Final comments

Sahar Bakr (ECA director), Rebecca Beech (ECA Director), Dermot Breslin (PRC Dean)

  • Update on Peer Review College events
  • Joining ECA and future events

Who Should Attend?

Early career scholars and PhD candidates


Facilitators
Dr Sahar Bakr

Dr Sahar Bakr

Senior Lecturer and Researcher in Marketing, Nottingham Trent University

Dr Rebecca Beech

Dr Rebecca Beech

SIG Sub-Committee

Dr Nisreen Ameen

Dr Nisreen Ameen

Track Co-Chair

Professor Paul Jones

Professor Paul Jones

Head of School of Management, Swansea University, UK

Professor Dermot Breslin
Professor Martin Spring

Professor Martin Spring

Professor of Operations Management, Lancaster University


Event Fee 
BAM Members: Free
Non-Members: £60

Registrations close on the 9th June 2025 at 17:00 UK time

If you are booking multiple paid events as a Non-Member, it may be cheaper for you to purchase a BAM Membership as nearly all BAM Events are free or at a discounted rate for Members.

For more information, please visit BAM Membership.

Contact us via e-mail at [email protected] should you have any queries.